{
 "blyg": "0.4",
 "id": "69vyxhajdwh0kmcmxjkwc71zyy",
 "kind": "thread",
 "origin": "https://notionparallax.co.uk/",
 "page": "https://notionparallax.co.uk/2015/fluid-categories-define-things-by-their-attributes-not-their-name-2",
 "author": {
  "name": "Ben Doherty",
  "url": "https://notionparallax.co.uk/"
 },
 "created": "2015-08-23T21:00:12Z",
 "updated": "2015-08-23T21:00:12Z",
 "version": 1,
 "content_md": "# Fluid categories - define things by their attributes not their name\n\n\n> Categories[^1] are an emergent way of describing set creation operations based on attributes\n\nMost of what I want to say here is taken directly from an old post on the BVN internal blog that I called *Taxonomy.* I'll summarize it here and copy that post below so that you don't need to go looking.\n\nhttps://youtu.be/05WS0WN7zMQ\n\nIn the video above Richard Feynman[^2] tells a story about naming things. He separates the _name_ of something from what that thing _is_[1. I think that this is the way ]. This is a safe and future proof w[^3]irectly categorising things is lazy thinking and asking for trouble!\n\n<hr />\n\nI made this presentation to explain how data is organised these days.\n\nIt's part of the work on the People and Projects data cleaning, so I'll refer to that throughout. It's applicable to a lot of other things though so keep an open mind and it might be interesting.\n\n<a href=\"http://notionparallax.co.uk/wordpress/wp-content/uploads/2015/08/taxonomy_Page_01.png\"><img class=\"alignnone size-large wp-image-18183\" src=\"https://notionparallax.co.uk/assets/taxonomy_Page_01-1024x575.png\" alt=\"taxonomy_Page_01\" width=\"640\" height=\"359\" /></a>\n\n<img class=\"alignright size-medium wp-image-18201\" src=\"https://notionparallax.co.uk/assets/eyore-300x216.png\" alt=\"eyore\" width=\"300\" height=\"216\" />People have always been interested in how to group like-things together. Methods of filing, organisation, classification, have taken up thousands of hours of discussion. There's even a whole job title and academic discipline associated with taxonomy. Departments of library science etc.\n\nThere is a problem with old fashioned filing of physical items though:\n\n<img class=\"alignnone size-full wp-image-18184\" src=\"https://notionparallax.co.uk/assets/taxonomy_Page_08.png\" alt=\"taxonomy_Page_08\" width=\"5334\" height=\"3000\" />\n\n<img class=\"alignnone size-full wp-image-18185\" src=\"https://notionparallax.co.uk/assets/taxonomy_Page_09.png\" alt=\"taxonomy_Page_09\" width=\"2934\" height=\"1650\" />\n\nAlmost everything we work with is <a href=\"http://philosophybites.com/2007/08/timothy-william.html\">vague</a> in one way or another. Consider organising these shapes:\n\n<img src=\"https://notionparallax.co.uk/assets/classes.gif\" alt=\"classes\" />\n\nHow do we know if she's a witch? She's either a witch or not a witch right?\n\nhttps://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zrzMhU_4m-g\n\nLuckily a new method of filing has emerged. By adding metadata to things[^4] we are able to filter things out of a giant pile really quickly.<img class=\"alignnone wp-image-18182 size-full\" src=\"https://notionparallax.co.uk/assets/pile.gif\" alt=\"pile\" width=\"800\" height=\"450\" />\n\nThe computer is able to make a big sieve that only lets through things that have certain **attributes**.\n\n<a href=\"http://notionparallax.co.uk/wordpress/wp-content/uploads/2015/08/taxonomy_Page_11.png\"><img class=\"alignnone wp-image-18186 size-full\" title=\"This is a small dolphin. Orca are technically dolphin too and they are a lot more than 40kg!\" src=\"https://notionparallax.co.uk/assets/taxonomy_Page_11.png\" alt=\"taxonomy_Page_11\" width=\"2880\" height=\"1620\" /></a>\n\nA person can have attributes, a project can too. The big questions of our time are about what that means, and what we can do with that knowledge!\n\nWhat's really cool is that you can stack these sieves so that you can combine the filters. <a href=\"http://notionparallax.co.uk/wordpress/wp-content/uploads/2015/08/taxonomy_Page_14.png\"><img class=\"alignnone size-full wp-image-18187\" src=\"https://notionparallax.co.uk/assets/taxonomy_Page_14.png\" alt=\"taxonomy_Page_14\" width=\"5334\" height=\"3000\" /></a> <a href=\"http://notionparallax.co.uk/wordpress/wp-content/uploads/2015/08/taxonomy_Page_15.png\"><img class=\"alignnone size-full wp-image-18188\" src=\"https://notionparallax.co.uk/assets/taxonomy_Page_15.png\" alt=\"taxonomy_Page_15\" width=\"5334\" height=\"3000\" /></a>\n\n<a href=\"http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/0387940944/ref=as_li_tl?ie=UTF8&amp;camp=1789&amp;creative=390957&amp;creativ same thing as someone else if it suits their needs, but if they have new needs they aren't forced to pick a \"next best thing\" option.\n\n<h2>Downsides</h2>\n\n<img class=\"alignright\" src=\"https://notionparallax.co.uk/assets/stalin2.jpg\" alt=\"\" width=\"240\" height=\"377\" />With free-form tagging, even with cool, advanced versions with typeahead support and synonyms there are downsides.\n\nIf you have megalomaniac tendencies, or a god complex. free-form tagging is no good. You are ceding control to your vassals. You don't get to have total control over your taxonomy. You should be wary of this if you don't trust your staff.\n\nThe other downside is a bit more subtle and easier to work with. Tags and content in general needs to be gardened. This means that every so often someone needs to convert all the \"HOuse\" tags into \"House\" tags.\n\n<h1>\"OK you weird nerd, why are you telling me this?\"</h1>\n\nWell, mainly because I like you. I do this stuff and I might as well share what I'm thinking with people.\n\nSecondly it's part of the grand project to sort out all our data, so I'm sharing my philosophy of data with you and I'd love if you could ask me questions and probe the bits that I've missed. I'm looking for any comments, as aggressive as you like, about how we can make our data capture better!\n\n<a href=\"http://notionparallax.co.uk/wordpress/wp-content/uploads/2015/08/taxonomy_Page_21.png\"><img class=\"alignnone size-full wp-image-18194\" src=\"https://notionparallax.co.uk/assets/taxonomy_Page_21.png\" alt=\"taxonomy_Page_21\" width=\" same thing as someone else if it suits their needs, but if they have new needs they aren't forced to pick a \"next best thing\" option.\n\n[^1]: I recognise that I don't know any Category Theory and not a great deal of Set Theory. I might be committing horrible sins with this statement. It works in it's naive context though.\n[^2]: One of my heroes. If he isn't one of yours then he really should be!\n[^3]: I think that this is the way\n[^4]: Yes the same metadata that all the fuss is about in the news\n",
 "content_html": "<h1>Fluid categories - define things by their attributes not their name</h1>\n<blockquote>\n  <p>Categories<sup id=\"fnref:1\" role=\"doc-noteref\"><a href=\"https://notionparallax.co.uk/2015/fluid-categories-define-things-by-their-attributes-not-their-name-2#fn:1\" class=\"footnote\" rel=\"footnote\">1</a></sup> are an emergent way of describing set creation operations based on attributes</p>\n</blockquote>\n\n<p>Most of what I want to say here is taken directly from an old post on the BVN internal blog that I called <em>Taxonomy.</em> I’ll summarize it here and copy that post below so that you don’t need to go looking.</p>\n\n<p>https://youtu.be/05WS0WN7zMQ</p>\n\n<p>In the video above Richard Feynman<sup id=\"fnref:2\" role=\"doc-noteref\"><a href=\"https://notionparallax.co.uk/2015/fluid-categories-define-things-by-their-attributes-not-their-name-2#fn:2\" class=\"footnote\" rel=\"footnote\">2</a></sup> tells a story about naming things. He separates the <em>name</em> of something from what that thing <em>is</em>[1. I think that this is the way ]. This is a safe and future proof w<sup id=\"fnref:3\" role=\"doc-noteref\"><a href=\"https://notionparallax.co.uk/2015/fluid-categories-define-things-by-their-attributes-not-their-name-2#fn:3\" class=\"footnote\" rel=\"footnote\">3</a></sup>irectly categorising things is lazy thinking and asking for trouble!</p>\n\n<hr />\n\n<p>I made this presentation to explain how data is organised these days.</p>\n\n<p>It’s part of the work on the People and Projects data cleaning, so I’ll refer to that throughout. It’s applicable to a lot of other things though so keep an open mind and it might be interesting.</p>\n\n<p><a href=\"http://notionparallax.co.uk/wordpress/wp-content/uploads/2015/08/taxonomy_Page_01.png\"><img class=\"alignnone size-large wp-image-18183\" src=\"https://notionparallax.co.uk/assets/taxonomy_Page_01-1024x575.png\" alt=\"taxonomy_Page_01\" width=\"640\" height=\"359\" /></a></p>\n\n<p><img class=\"alignright size-medium wp-image-18201\" src=\"https://notionparallax.co.uk/assets/eyore-300x216.png\" alt=\"eyore\" width=\"300\" height=\"216\" />People have always been interested in how to group like-things together. Methods of filing, organisation, classification, have taken up thousands of hours of discussion. There’s even a whole job title and academic discipline associated with taxonomy. Departments of library science etc.</p>\n\n<p>There is a problem with old fashioned filing of physical items though:</p>\n\n<p><img class=\"alignnone size-full wp-image-18184\" src=\"https://notionparallax.co.uk/assets/taxonomy_Page_08.png\" alt=\"taxonomy_Page_08\" width=\"5334\" height=\"3000\" /></p>\n\n<p><img class=\"alignnone size-full wp-image-18185\" src=\"https://notionparallax.co.uk/assets/taxonomy_Page_09.png\" alt=\"taxonomy_Page_09\" width=\"2934\" height=\"1650\" /></p>\n\n<p>Almost everything we work with is <a href=\"http://philosophybites.com/2007/08/timothy-william.html\">vague</a> in one way or another. Consider organising these shapes:</p>\n\n<p><img src=\"https://notionparallax.co.uk/assets/classes.gif\" alt=\"classes\" /></p>\n\n<p>How do we know if she’s a witch? She’s either a witch or not a witch right?</p>\n\n<p>https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=zrzMhU_4m-g</p>\n\n<p>Luckily a new method of filing has emerged. By adding metadata to things<sup id=\"fnref:4\" role=\"doc-noteref\"><a href=\"https://notionparallax.co.uk/2015/fluid-categories-define-things-by-their-attributes-not-their-name-2#fn:4\" class=\"footnote\" rel=\"footnote\">4</a></sup> we are able to filter things out of a giant pile really quickly.<img class=\"alignnone wp-image-18182 size-full\" src=\"https://notionparallax.co.uk/assets/pile.gif\" alt=\"pile\" width=\"800\" height=\"450\" /></p>\n\n<p>The computer is able to make a big sieve that only lets through things that have certain <strong>attributes</strong>.</p>\n\n<p><a href=\"http://notionparallax.co.uk/wordpress/wp-content/uploads/2015/08/taxonomy_Page_11.png\"><img class=\"alignnone wp-image-18186 size-full\" title=\"This is a small dolphin. Orca are technically dolphin too and they are a lot more than 40kg!\" src=\"https://notionparallax.co.uk/assets/taxonomy_Page_11.png\" alt=\"taxonomy_Page_11\" width=\"2880\" height=\"1620\" /></a></p>\n\n<p>A person can have attributes, a project can too. The big questions of our time are about what that means, and what we can do with that knowledge!</p>\n\n<p>What’s really cool is that you can stack these sieves so that you can combine the filters. <a href=\"http://notionparallax.co.uk/wordpress/wp-content/uploads/2015/08/taxonomy_Page_14.png\"><img class=\"alignnone size-full wp-image-18187\" src=\"https://notionparallax.co.uk/assets/taxonomy_Page_14.png\" alt=\"taxonomy_Page_14\" width=\"5334\" height=\"3000\" /></a> <a href=\"http://notionparallax.co.uk/wordpress/wp-content/uploads/2015/08/taxonomy_Page_15.png\"><img class=\"alignnone size-full wp-image-18188\" src=\"https://notionparallax.co.uk/assets/taxonomy_Page_15.png\" alt=\"taxonomy_Page_15\" width=\"5334\" height=\"3000\" /></a></p>\n\n<p>&lt;a href=”http://www.amazon.com/gp/product/0387940944/ref=as_li_tl?ie=UTF8&amp;camp=1789&amp;creative=390957&amp;creativ same thing as someone else if it suits their needs, but if they have new needs they aren’t forced to pick a “next best thing” option.</p>\n\n<h2>Downsides</h2>\n\n<p><img class=\"alignright\" src=\"https://notionparallax.co.uk/assets/stalin2.jpg\" alt=\"\" width=\"240\" height=\"377\" />With free-form tagging, even with cool, advanced versions with typeahead support and synonyms there are downsides.</p>\n\n<p>If you have megalomaniac tendencies, or a god complex. free-form tagging is no good. You are ceding control to your vassals. You don’t get to have total control over your taxonomy. You should be wary of this if you don’t trust your staff.</p>\n\n<p>The other downside is a bit more subtle and easier to work with. Tags and content in general needs to be gardened. This means that every so often someone needs to convert all the “HOuse” tags into “House” tags.</p>\n\n<h1>“OK you weird nerd, why are you telling me this?”</h1>\n\n<p>Well, mainly because I like you. I do this stuff and I might as well share what I’m thinking with people.</p>\n\n<p>Secondly it’s part of the grand project to sort out all our data, so I’m sharing my philosophy of data with you and I’d love if you could ask me questions and probe the bits that I’ve missed. I’m looking for any comments, as aggressive as you like, about how we can make our data capture better!</p>\n\n<p><a href=\"http://notionparallax.co.uk/wordpress/wp-content/uploads/2015/08/taxonomy_Page_21.png\">&lt;img class=”alignnone size-full wp-image-18194” src=”/assets/taxonomy_Page_21.png” alt=”taxonomy_Page_21” width=” same thing as someone else if it suits their needs, but if they have new needs they aren’t forced to pick a “next best thing” option.</a></p>\n\n<div class=\"footnotes\" role=\"doc-endnotes\">\n  <ol>\n    <li id=\"fn:1\" role=\"doc-endnote\">\n      <p>I recognise that I don’t know any Category Theory and not a great deal of Set Theory. I might be committing horrible sins with this statement. It works in it’s naive context though. <a href=\"https://notionparallax.co.uk/2015/fluid-categories-define-things-by-their-attributes-not-their-name-2#fnref:1\" class=\"reversefootnote\" role=\"doc-backlink\">&#8617;</a></p>\n    </li>\n    <li id=\"fn:2\" role=\"doc-endnote\">\n      <p>One of my heroes. If he isn’t one of yours then he really should be! <a href=\"https://notionparallax.co.uk/2015/fluid-categories-define-things-by-their-attributes-not-their-name-2#fnref:2\" class=\"reversefootnote\" role=\"doc-backlink\">&#8617;</a></p>\n    </li>\n    <li id=\"fn:3\" role=\"doc-endnote\">\n      <p>I think that this is the way <a href=\"https://notionparallax.co.uk/2015/fluid-categories-define-things-by-their-attributes-not-their-name-2#fnref:3\" class=\"reversefootnote\" role=\"doc-backlink\">&#8617;</a></p>\n    </li>\n    <li id=\"fn:4\" role=\"doc-endnote\">\n      <p>Yes the same metadata that all the fuss is about in the news <a href=\"https://notionparallax.co.uk/2015/fluid-categories-define-things-by-their-attributes-not-their-name-2#fnref:4\" class=\"reversefootnote\" role=\"doc-backlink\">&#8617;</a></p>\n    </li>\n  </ol>\n</div>\n",
 "content_hash": "sha256:768de3fd963576020bdee7fead8b9396bf2c2deb30f3cf6fdc34f66921ab9b3a",
 "media": [],
 "changelog": [
  {
   "version": 1,
   "at": "2015-08-23T21:00:12Z",
   "note": null
  }
 ],
 "transclusions": []
}